Cola and turkey in the same sentence, and you’ve already raised an eyebrow. That’s normal. But here’s the reality: this recipe is probably the most reliable in your holiday repertoire — the slow cooker does the work, the cola makes the glaze, and you do something else.

The first thing you notice is the color. A shiny mahogany brown, somewhere between light caramel and full-bodied coffee. The surface is glistening, a bit sticky, with spots where the sugar has really caught and formed a thin crust. When you get closer, there’s this sweet-smoky scent floating around — a mix of warm molasses and mustard that you didn’t expect. The meat underneath is white and juicy, almost falling apart without a knife.